My experiences as a humanitarian worker in South America, with a little philosophy thrown in for kicks.
Sunday, June 12, 2011
Buen día, Rivadavia
“Good day to all the town of Rivadavia, it's always a pleasure to be able to talk to you”. That's probably the most nerve-wracking phrase I've had to speak (in Spanish, of course) in my experience thus far as director of this project, because every time I have to say it I'm “on the air”.
Radio is a big deal here. In a small, rural town where access to TV is limited and illiteracy rates are uncomfortably high, radio still reigns as the king of local news, music, and advertising. Television is definitely present—both cable and satellite (DirecTV)–but with no local programming, the majority of TV viewing time goes to fútbol (soccer), novelas (soap operas), or pelis (movies). These things offer entertainment, but they do not—I would argue—provide the same feeling of interconnectedness with a community that listening to the radio can. And, of course, buying a radio is simply cheaper.
To further prove my point is this fact: there are three radio stations in Rivadavia. The community station, run by the municipal government, plays a mix of everything and is the most popular, followed by the other two, which are privately owned and broadcast exclusively evangelical Christian content.
Interestingly, despite their influence, they are surprisingly willing to give out free air time. And that's where we come in. Since we are doing so many things both in the town and in the community, the most effective way to get out a message is by dropping by the radio once or twice a week and announcing it on the air. Now that we are friends with most of the staff, we can basically just show up and within 5 minutes be in the studio talking about the latest plan or meeting to the entire Rivadavia area. The only unfortunate part is that the other ADRA team members seem to think it's most appropriate that I talk the most because I'm director of the project, even though I am obviously the least fluent in Spanish.
The truth is, though, that even with the semi-present language barrier, by the time I'm actually talking and conversing with the host I feel almost entirely comfortable. For some reason, despite all the nerves I have just beforehand, in the actual moment when I have no choice but to speak I get a wave of inexplicable fearlessness. Even if my words are simple and I make mistakes in pronunciation or conjugation, something about that spontaneous moment in which I am only subconsciously aware of the hundreds of people that might be listening frees me of my normal social inhibition. It's exhilarating, but strange; why is it that talking with more people would make me feel less afraid than talking with just one or two?
I still don't have a good answer for that question, but I do know that I love being a part of the radio medium. Before I arrived in Rivadavia I had actually started a weekly radio program with my friend Brian called “Teh 402 Show”. Using a rather clever combination of internet technology (Skype, Gmail phone, Ustream, and Facebook), we were able to broadcast our discussions, play our favorite music choices, and even take calls and texts. Even though we never got too many listeners, the idea of communicating with an audience was not only fun but fulfilling. In an age when we are overstimulated by the visual, the experience of sitting back and listening to a conversation or a song or a story is still incredibly compelling.
And here in Rivadavia, it's even more important. Being a constant presence on the radio not only helps our project to be better known the Wichí community, it also brings their situation to light in the community at-large. That heightened awareness of the problem is, in my eyes, the first step towards deeper understanding and less discrimination. By breaking down my language barrier, perhaps at the same time I am helping to topple bigger walls.
Friday, June 3, 2011
Flexibilidad
Less than two weeks into the project, we had already found ourselves in a plan B situation. We had come in strong on all fronts, creating positive, strong and mutually beneficial relationships with every institution in Rivadavia, except for the one about which we cared about the most: the Wichí community. It wasn't so much that our plans to reach out had gone sour... they just hadn't gone anywhere. Our attempts to draw people to meetings hadn't worked, so we did the opposite: we went to them.
It's never easy to break the ice when you arrive at the house of someone you don't know. Anyone who was coerced into door-to-door fundraisers in elementary school knows exactly what I'm talking about. Obviously we weren't selling chocolate or frozen pizzas or wrapping paper (curse you Sligo!), but we were, in a way, selling an idea. We had to sell the idea that we weren't selling anything, that we were there to help without asking anything in return. I am convinced that it is infinitely more difficult to do that than it is to sell an actual product. You always know what the motive of a salesman is, so it's really just the quality or necessity of the product that is up for debate. In our case, both our motives and our “product” are in question.
We had been going to houses all week to tell them about the upcoming survey, and at the end of each day it still seemed like there were countless more that we hadn't visited yet, or even seen before. Progress was relatively slow because we preferred to go as a group rather than split up. In the end we hoped this would save us time: by going together with our Wichí assistant/translator (Silvana), we could ensure that the message was understood and well-received in a single visit. Going solo meant risking misunderstandings—and repeat visits to clear them up. So, slowly but surely we were reaching the majority of the houses, and after a few long days at the end of the week we had reached virtually all of them on time, ready for the day of the survey on Sunday (22nd of June).
Planning a community-wide survey of over 100 houses in one day is hard. It's even harder when you're not exactly sure where all the houses are and you don't have any standardized way of identifying them. It's harder still your survey is in a different language than the mother tongue of the people from whom you want to collect relatively complicated information (nutrition, education levels, medical history, work history, etc.). And, to top it all off, the majority of the people conducting your survey are teenagers who have never done one before, and you will be held responsible if they mess up.
Almost always I find that the level of stress I have about a specific problem is not at all proportional to the actual amount of work required to solve it. I'm not sure if I'm just speaking for myself on this point, but when I stress out a lot about a problem that seems impossible to fix, the solution is actually quite simple or presents itself on it's own (for example, one day after talking with a few members of the community, we learned that many families would soon be leaving for a month to find temporary work in a field 100 miles away. After stressing out—no, freaking out—for the rest of the afternoon about how the survey would be pointless and the whole project would have to be put on hold, a simple call to Beatriz revealed that only very few young men would go, never entire families. Problem solved.)
Fortunately this was the case for the nearly all of difficulties facing us for the survey. For weeks we had been asking the hospital if they had a map of the houses that they used as a guide for making their rounds, Silvana—who also works in the hospital—decided to simply sit down and make one herself. Although she is from La Esperanza, a Wichí community 20 miles away, she somehow created a rough sketch of every house in La Misión without even going to the community for reference—it even had names on each house. After a short discussion about spacing and layout, I copied it to a smaller piece of paper that we could hand out to each team leader. Problem solved.
The survey being in a different language was an issue we had been discussing since about a month ago when we had begun developing it. Here we were in Rivadavia and we were still debating whether we needed to translate it, and if so, how we would proctor it. After a five-minute talk with the public health agent who works in La Misión, we found out that he had no problems with communication even though he knows no Wichí and the hospital's questions were much more complicated than ours. Problem solved. (Well, almost. We still had to simplify and format our questionnaire, which did take a very, very long time.)
As for the unprepared surveyors, we were very concerned that perhaps our course hadn't adequately prepared them for being out in the field, especially with the differences in age and culture. Yet, on “D-Day”, we were all pleasantly surprised by the quality of the work they did. To get an early start, we had arranged to meet at 8:30 AM—on a Sunday. Even so, nearly everyone arrived even before we did, and no one was late. Throughout the day they showed respect, responsibility, and a genuine interest in completing the survey patiently, accurately and effectively. And we finished all of the houses before lunch. Problem solved—or maybe it was never there at all.
That's not to say that there weren't difficult moments. For one, of the two survey forms I sent to Beatriz to photocopy, she printed the older one, which was missing some important changes. Photocopies are ridiculously expensive here (50 centavos/page), so we had to hand-write some of the questions and staple in the extra sheet for about 120 forms. There was also some confusion about the map not being not exactly to scale, making it unclear where some houses were supposed to be located, and some houses were missing entirely. Another complicating factor was that on the day of the survey there were a few families that were at church, weren't at home, or were visiting in other parts of the community. There were also a very small number—two—who did not want to participate at all (somehow, nearly all of these cases occurred in my “zone” of about 30 houses). And it was a strangely hot autumn day, so we had to plan to return on another day to finish the seven or eight missing homes.
Needless to say that Sunday afternoon was a huge relief. I was dying from the heat and still on an adrenaline-high from the kind of nerves that can only come from worrying about being responsible for large amounts of other people. But I was happy. Plan B had worked.
Other moments that stand out:
Our new friend Pablo, who invited us into his home when we told him about the survey, and him repaying the visit at our house to talk again even though he was under the weather.
The four policemen we had asked oversee the survey being totally confused about the need for their presence, but patiently standing around anyways.
The negative body language of Pedro (one of the two who didn't want to participate) as he told us that he had already been surveyed, even though we knew he hadn't.
The old man who I mentioned in my last post being so excited to be surveyed that he bee-lined directly to us to let us know that we hadn't gone to his house yet!
The speeches of our students about their experiences during the survey at the final meeting of the training course, talking about how much it impacted them to see how people that lived so close to them were in such desperate need.
Carrying two enormous frozen goat carcasses by myself eight blocks across town for our asado (barbecue) to celebrate the termination of the course and the success of the survey.
Sunday, May 22, 2011
Cambios grandes, pasos pequeños
A very exhausting week had gone by, but I wasn't nearly as tired as I was apprehensive. Why? Beatriz was leaving.
From the very start of the planning of this project back in July, my name had been in the spot I least wanted it to be: director. To most people it would be strange for them to hear me say that. There are countless times where I've stood out as a natural leader, even when I didn't intend to, or indeed even when some of the people I was “leading” weren't very happy about it. The truth is, though, that I would much rather just follow someone else and have a specific task to complete. The problem is that in doing my work I always seem to be able to find time to see the errors of the other people working alongside me, and then feel the need to take control so as to minimize those errors. I suppose the jury is still out on if that is a fundamentally positive or negative aspect of my personality. Either way, not having Beatriz to follow scared me to death. I began recognizing all of the things that she had been able to accomplish so easily, realizing that my talents were nothing next to hers.
But this is what I chose. I could have backed out whenever I wanted to. Certainly I did not have the wit, tact, and spontaneity that draws everyone to Beatriz, but I did have one thing: dedication. A lot of it.
With that in mind, we cleared up some technical details and laid out a general plan for the following three weeks until she would be back again. We moved into a rented house (with a large room that conveniently can be used as a depository for donations) which was actually quite cozy once we cleaned out all the cobwebs and arranged a few pieces of furniture. Bathroom, hot water (electric heater), and gas stove, all for $125/month. A steal. We became fast friends with our landlord—the local justice of the peace—whose wife even promised to make us homemade bread every week.
As for the project plan, we settled on a single objective: do a house-by-house survey of every home in the community. Even though we already have a general idea of the necessities of the Wichí, to begin organizing the community—the first phase of the project—it would be necessary to have a very clear idea of how many families live in La Misión, and know exactly what problems they are facing. Given that there are only four of us here permanently—two social workers from the UAP (Silvana and Laly), a veteran ADRA volunteer (July), and myself—such a large scale survey would be very time consuming without some extra help. So, we decided to run a class in the town of Rivadavia to formally train students and adults in the art of surveying, promising a certificate and the possibility of future work in the area.
Preparing for the class was a little intimidating. Because of our lack of internet, we had very little source material, and it had been quite some time since Research Methods from college. Even then, my knowledge is oriented much more towards the construction and analysis of a survey or test than it is on what we needed to train people in: the interviewing process itself. In the end, however, that didn't matter as much as I thought it would. Silvana and Laly came up with some great material and activities on their own, and it turned out that what was much more helpful was my extensive training in PowerPoint layout and organization (a skill acquired from my wonderful psychology professors). Apart from the 15 elementary school teachers who dropped out of the course at the last minute because of conflicting meetings, things have gone incredibly well after the first week of classes. Even if the 30 people who did show up didn't fully understand the lecture I gave on Thursday, they were at least nice enough to pretend they did!
When we weren't working on the class, we were doing our best to inform members of La Misión about who we are and what we are doing. This was without doubt the more challenging half of our workload. There are so many barriers between “us” and “them” that it is very difficult to communicate effectively. It is not simply that our language and culture are vastly different. A long history of manipulation and false promises has made the Wichí extremely skeptical of outsiders, even those—maybe even especially those—who come in the name of help and support. In order to get our message across, we either have to oversimplify it or spend a significant amount of time explaining it in detail, neither of which are very appealing options. By simplifying we run the risk of having the other person fill in the details themselves, which can lead to serious errors—for example, thinking that we are a political group. By spending too much time on any given conversation, we are limiting the already small amount of time we have to reach other members of the community.
Most of the time the most we can expect is a muffled si or a slight nod of the head, but every once in awhile there are a few that open up and talking feels much more rewarding. For me this usually happens with the men of the community, with whom I feel more comfortable as I ask about fútbol or the history of La Misión or what they do for a living. Of course these topics are somewhat superficial, but they also create exactly the kind of confidence we are trying to gain, opening the door for more serious ideas—ADRA, plans for the future, community organization, etc.—to be discussed.
This was perhaps most true as we conversed with two of the teachers from the bilingual annex (Wichí-Spanish) to the elementary school in the community. Other times when we visited on other business, Beatriz and I had talked with them briefly as they sat outside watching over children at recess. Those times that we met they seemed to be rather non-plussed by our presence, and they were quick to mention other projects that had come before and failed. At one point one of them, Demetrio, had even spoken against the housing project in the name of all Wichí (“Los Wichí no estamos de acuerdo con...”). Later on we discovered that he might have in fact had the right to do so, because he is the de facto cacique of La Misión (see previous post), although most in the community do not recognize him as such. With this new information I felt the need to speak with him again, and although he still maintained some distance I think something changed in that moment. As I spoke, I could not help but voice how dedicated we are to helping La Misión, how much we feel their pain, how committed we are to not let things keep happening that way, and how this time things will be different.
Clearly what I say—or what anyone in our group says—is not the only important factor in achieving the closeness we are looking for. Having a bilingual aid, even though she is from another community, has been elemental to much of our progress. But after that conversation, I stopped feeling nervous about confronting the issues and, more importantly, I started to see a change in how people reacted to me. Now they seem to be listening more to what I say, and are more likely to enter into a real conversation--even offer to help us reach out to others.
And Demetrio greets me with a smile.
Other moments that stand out:
“You guys need to have neighborhoods with streets and houses. You have to stop living like animals”, the words of the agricultural surveyor of the municipal government to one of the pastors of the Wichí Anglican church in La Misión.
Talking with the two cooks at the “school cafeteria” (3-walled structure with a grill over a hole) about what they make for the children, where they get their food from, and what they thought about our project.
Discussing the possibility of a bilingual dictionary with Demetrio and his co-worker
Realizing how expansive and disperse the community really is. In some places you could walk for almost two miles from one end to the other.
Mispronouncing “democracy” multiple times during my presentation.
Talking with a nearly deaf elderly man who had been sleeping with the radio on full blast playing Lady Gaga. When he finally came out to talk to us, he was legitimately interested in everything we were doing, and made sure he remembered our names.
Saturday, May 14, 2011
¡Gracias, REVO!
To the REVO team and all of PUC:
Although words alone cannot express my gratitude for all that you have done, I cannot go without saying a few things. First: thank you, thank you, THANK YOU. Although I am thousands of miles away, your effort, dedication, and generosity have had a profound effect both on me and on ADRA's work here in Argentina. Simply put, this project would have been impossible without your help. You have chosen not only to help people in need, but to bring attention to the many problems facing the indigenous cultures of Argentina, a reality that most people would rather forget or ignore.
As a former student at PUC, I know that sometimes it can be difficult to feel that you are really making a difference, but your participation in REVO—in whatever way you might have been a part of it—is a clear example that you are not “waiting on the world to change”. The revolution of REVO has just as much to do with creating positive change in the world as it does with creating that same change within ourselves: increasing our awareness of what is really happening around us, and refusing to let it stay that way. It is saying NO to poverty, sickness, and death. NO to injustice, prejudice and oppression. And ultimately, NO to complacency, stagnancy, and ignorance. Whether that “NO” is a quiet whisper in the back of your mind or a shout on the tip of your tongue, it must never be silenced. The passion and compassion we have for others is what unites us, and indeed it is the only thing that makes life worth living.
So again, I say thanks to all of you. To the REVO team for their hard work, to President Knight for her incredible generosity—along with other other anonymous donors—and to PUC, my beloved alma mater. Our ADRA team is working tirelessly to make this shared vision a reality, and we are forever indebted to your service. Thank you.
Although words alone cannot express my gratitude for all that you have done, I cannot go without saying a few things. First: thank you, thank you, THANK YOU. Although I am thousands of miles away, your effort, dedication, and generosity have had a profound effect both on me and on ADRA's work here in Argentina. Simply put, this project would have been impossible without your help. You have chosen not only to help people in need, but to bring attention to the many problems facing the indigenous cultures of Argentina, a reality that most people would rather forget or ignore.
As a former student at PUC, I know that sometimes it can be difficult to feel that you are really making a difference, but your participation in REVO—in whatever way you might have been a part of it—is a clear example that you are not “waiting on the world to change”. The revolution of REVO has just as much to do with creating positive change in the world as it does with creating that same change within ourselves: increasing our awareness of what is really happening around us, and refusing to let it stay that way. It is saying NO to poverty, sickness, and death. NO to injustice, prejudice and oppression. And ultimately, NO to complacency, stagnancy, and ignorance. Whether that “NO” is a quiet whisper in the back of your mind or a shout on the tip of your tongue, it must never be silenced. The passion and compassion we have for others is what unites us, and indeed it is the only thing that makes life worth living.
So again, I say thanks to all of you. To the REVO team for their hard work, to President Knight for her incredible generosity—along with other other anonymous donors—and to PUC, my beloved alma mater. Our ADRA team is working tirelessly to make this shared vision a reality, and we are forever indebted to your service. Thank you.
Saturday, May 7, 2011
Empezando con el proceso del cambio
“¡Zach!”
“¿Qué?” I respond, more than half asleep.
“¡¡¡ZACH!!!”
“¿Qué pasa?”, still disoriented.
“I think they are taking some of our stuff off the bus!”, said Beatriz (in Spanish, of course).
“Tranquila, Bety. No pasa nada...”, as I drift back into my dream.
Surely there was some danger of losing some of our cargo--by malice or more likely by accident—simply because there was just so much of it; somehow we had fit what seemed like an endless amount of boxes and bags in the carriage of our bus. But after having travelled so many times like this, I had learned to worry about lost bags at the end of the trip. There's just not much you can do, and I desperately needed sleep as we made the big move from Salta Capital to Rivadavia, an 8-hour overnight ride on mostly dirt roads.
We arrived at around 8:30 in the morning, probably exhausted more from the preparation and rush to the bus terminal in Salta than the trip itself. Fermín, Secretary to the municipal government of Rivadavia and our main contact in the region, eventually arrived with his pick-up truck to take us to the hospedaje where we would be staying for the next week or so as we settled in.
And then the fun began.
As soon as we had unloaded our gear and eaten the semblance of a breakfast, we were on our way to meetings. Meetings and meetings and meetings, to establish ourselves in the community and form mutual relationships with institutions that will help us reach our goals.
But first, some political context. Rivadavia is a small town--probably about 3000 inhabitants--which is surrounded by indigenous Wichí communities, some closeby (1km), some quite far away and isolated (60km or more). Even so, the politics are fierce and dirty. In terms of elections, buying votes with favors is commonplace, and often politicians will provide transportation to the voting booth on election day to ensure they get that community's vote. Once in office, the situation doesn't improve very much. Conflicts of interest are well-known and accepted (for example, the Director of Public Works also owns the company that builds public housing units), work is slow and inconsistent, and the mayor--who has a 7th grade education and recently won his 3rd term--is never here. Earlier this year when Rivadavia was in crisis due to flooding, it took his staff almost two days to find him. He was at a folklore fiesta in the wine-country town of Cafayate. Needless to say, most people seem to be in disagreement with the government in general, but are also typically dependent on it for their welfare, however mismanaged the process might be.
Since I don't want to bore everyone with every detail of every meeting over the last week, I'll outline here what happened at each place:
MUNICIPAL GOV'T
Main contact: Fermín (Secretary)
What we asked for: Technical, financial, and moral support for the project
What we were offering: Improved quality of life for citizens
Most important thing learned: A housing project had begun in “our” community (La Misión), with 40 homes being constructed and 40 more promised
Most impacting images: The run-down building and primitive technology; the line of Wichí waiting to submit requests and complaints with the gov't
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Main contact: Director
What we asked for: Attendance records for children from La Misón
What we were offering: Assessment of children with learning disabilities by two social workers on our team
Most important thing learned: A shockingly small percentage of children who finish 4th grade in the school located in the community continue on to the 5th grade located in the town, and those who do are in segregated classes
Most impacting images: The classroom of Wichí children reading their dictionaries; a quote on the main blackboard about the cultural value and richness of the indigenous peoples of Argentina
HIGH SCHOOL
Main contact: Director
What we asked for: Students who might be interested in volunteering in the project
What we were offering: Guest lectures in our areas of specialty
Most important thing learned: Only 1 or 2 Wichí youth finish high school every year
HOSPITAL
Main contact: Director
What we asked for: Health records for inhabitants of La Misión; participation in community workshops on health
What we were offering: Donated medications and equipment; general help from our social workers
Most important thing learned: The water of Rivadavia, even in the town, is not drinkable (maximum level of arsenic in water should be below .01% according to the WHO. Here, it is .2%, 20 times the limit)
Most impacting image: two Wichí mothers—aged 13 and 15—nursing their babies
RADIO
Main contact: DJ
What we asked for: Permission to promote our project on the radio
What we were offering: Awareness
Most important thing learned: Listening to the radio is very common, and the staff is completely open to our participation
And finally, the community itself. La Misión is rather unique among Wichí communities. Unlike others we have visited, it lacks a central hub of homes and instead is comprised of a number of disperse hamlets, usually made up of only one or two extended families living in proximity. Also notable is the diversity of living conditions, ranging from stake and plastic lean-tos to humble adobe houses to full-on brick constructions. Most interesting, however, is their apparent lack of a cacique (chief). It is normal after the death of the cacique that there be some dispute about who be chosen for the position, but typically after a year or so most of the community will recognize the new leader. Not only has La Misión been missing a cacique for over two years, it appears that no one is really interested in having one. The priests of the local Anglican church seem to have any sway at all, and even then it is only over a very small portion of the community.
With no central leadership, La Misión has been left to a mild but consistent discord and disorganization amongst its' members. As you may imagine, this creates a difficult situation when you are trying to initiate a community-based project like ours. Each time we speak with a different member of the community we receive a slightly different story, coupled with different motives, different ideas... different everything.
There is one factor, however, that might turn all of that around. As I mentioned before, we found out that the rumored government plan to build houses in La Misión had indeed begun. This was indeed the most notable difference we encountered when we first arrived at the community. They had built a temporary structure as an annex to the defunct comedor (soup kitchen, although its an awful translation) to hold and prepare the building materials. A group of four or five men was cutting iron rods which would be later bound together to form posts for pouring concrete.
Why would public housing unite the community? First, because it would centralize most of the members in one place, providing the combination of having a defined center and living in proximity would, perhaps, promote the idea of living as one unit rather than separated groups. Second, because it gives the community a central project that they can all stand behind. Third, and most importantly, because it simply provides hope that positive change is possible.
Still, the project is not without it's difficulties. Since only 40 homes are being constructed in the first phase, certainly some families will be left out of the selection, an unfortunate reality which is possible even after all 80 homes are completed. Also, some people worry that the small plot of land on which the house rests will become their only land, that the government will try to snatch up the rest of the property that they believe belongs to them. Obviously this worry is not without cause, as such practices are common in the history of the Wichí and indeed virtually all indigenous peoples.
Since the public housing project is already taking place, we are trying to show the community how this is an opportunity to reach even higher goals. Certainly the improvement of living conditions is important, but the betterment of nutrition, higiene, and community integration are goals that are necessary to create a real change in the overall quality of life. Furthermore, the existence of a new community structure also will allow for a more formalized request for the legalization of indigenous lands.
And it is on those four goals—nutrition, hygiene, community organizaion, and land ownership—that we are dedicated. We have not yet focused heavily on hygiene, but this week we made important steps in the direction of completing the other three major goals. We met with the national institute for argiculture (INTA) who tested the water and proposed how and where we would start the farming process. We met with the surveyor to discuss the integration of our plan with that of the new housing units. And we met with community members to discuss their perception of our plan, their doubts and dreams, their needs. Slowly but surely we are showing them that we are a hand that is reaching out to help. I hope that eventually the community as a whole will see us as something more, not just as helpers but companions in their struggle. I think it is possible, and will continue to be more apparent as time presses on. As one of the pastors of the church said in the Friday evening service we attended, “we are all one below the same God”.
One of our key phrases this week has been “Rivadavia no es pobre. Solo está en una situación de pobreza”: Rivadavia is not poor. It is only in a situation of poverty. (The use of es versus está es elemental. Both are translated as “is”, but es is a conjugation of the verb ser, a verb for “to be” which implies permanency [e.g., I am a blonde, I am American], while está is a conjugation of estar, also meaning “to be” but in a more fluid sense of things that are changeable [e.g. I am sad, I am tired]). Although our main focus is on nutrition, a fundamental part of that process is showing both the community and the key institutions of Rivadavia that there is a richness here that is in grave danger of being lost if the status quo does not change. As I have noted before, the richness of the land is already being extracted by outside interests instead of being used to feed those who live on it, the rightful owners. At the same time, the richness of the Wichí culture is slowly disappearing because their communities are in a seemingly impossible struggle to simply survive. Our mission is to make sure those two processes are stopped, and hopefully someday reversed.
I don't have time to go into detail about all of the things I have seen and heard, but I'll leave you with some of the most important things I haven't yet mentioned:
- The pastors of the church conducting nearly all of their Friday service in Spanish simply because we were there, and them asking us to speak up front (very nerve-racking!)
- The children of the community drinking water directly from the water spout with putrifying water surrounding them, all the while knowing that the source is poisoned with arsenic
- The worn and wrinkled faces of women not even my mother's age
- The way the surveyor talked about the Wichís living like animals
- The Wichí children surrounding us while we snapped photos of them, laughing and playing and fighting and joking in both of our half-Spanish tongues
- The two women who were kind enough to come to our meeting even we had invited nearly half of the community (who didn't show up)
- The endless repetetive songs in the church
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Un día agridulce
Last minute errands. Stuffing my backpack again. Finalizing plans. The day has come.
And so it goes.
I have been waiting for this moment for over half a year, and yet I still cannot quite come to terms with it. Ever since the first trip we took to Rivadavia, I always wanted to stay longer, learn more, live amongst those who so many reject or simply forget. Most of my friends from down here think it's crazy that my dream was to come all the way from the United States to live in a place so desolate. But it was my dream, and it is at long last coming true.
I am excited, and I am afraid. Leaving a comfortable place is never easy, especially when on the other end there is a sea of unknowns and expectations. But I am jumping in. And after all, I am not going alone.
So I say an unsure farewell. But if all goes well and I can continue to keep in contact with you all, this good-bye will have been unnecessarily melodramatic and I will have to apologize for it :) Chau, amigos.
Monday, April 25, 2011
Luchando con el pueblo Wichí
In July of 2010 we went on a trip (read journey-project) to Rivadavia Banda Sur, a desert-like region on the western border of the Salta province that is without question one of the poorest places in Salta, if not all of Argentina. The population of Rivadavia Banda Sur is comprised almost exclusively of the indigenous Wichí, a group that has unfortunately suffered the plight of most indigenous peoples: subtle manipulation, overt oppression, and extreme poverty. Since it is so rural, they have been able to conserve most of their cultural traditions--most importantly their language--but their original way of life is becoming increasingly unsustainable. Deforestation and an increasingly violent climate cycle between drought and floods have all but destroyed their ability to maintain a hunter-gatherer existence, and as a result they now depend heavily on state welfare programs. (For more on this situation, read this piece from the BBC)
ADRA in Salta has an intense compassion for the Wichí and their struggle, visiting the region at least two to three times a year to provide much needed food, clothing, and other goods. Within the last year, however, ADRA's leadership has come to recognize that this is not enough. Although it is clear that giving food and clothing is an honorable task in the face of such great need, it is equally clear that doing so is much like placing a band-aid on a gaping wound. In other words, to create a real change, we must search out the source of the problem and begin working there.
Still, in Rivadavia Banda Sur, it's hard to know where to start. The situation is desperate: lack of access to drinking water, malnutrition, shack-like homes, unsanitary disposal of waste, little to no birth control, corroding schools... and the list goes on. But the saddest and most frustrating problem the Wichí are facing is much less apparent and much more dangerous. It is discrimination. To average Argentinian citizens and even some of the very people who supposedly represent and work for this group, the Wichí is dirty, a drunk, and above all, lazy--an indio. Thus, not only is the Wichí poor, he is told and often convinced that he has no choice but to be that way, that his suffering is not the result of his situation but his culture.
Given this gut-wrenching scenario, where DO you start? Something must be done, but what? How?
While we were on that trip back in July, one of the 33 communities we were able to reach had a particularly strong impact on us. It is called La Misión, and is about 1km from the small town of Rivadavia. In La Misión, the school "cafeteria" (photo left) was about 8 bricks in a circle, practically in the open air. When it rains, children go hungry. During vacations, children go hungry. When the government failed to send food, children go hungry. And not just children, because they often share their tiny rations with their family, most of whom are also malnourished. They asked for help, and we decided to respond.
But "doing good" isn't as easy as it sounds. Formulating a solution to a complex problem is itself a complex task. You have to consider all aspects of the problem and all of the potential positive--and negative--outcomes that your idea might generate once in place. But perhaps more important than the actual proposed solution is the attitude and perspective with which you do it. For example, if you believe that poverty is cultural, you would make one of two common mistakes: 1. try to change their culture (ethnocentrism), or 2. create assistance programs that help reduce suffering but do not resolve the root issues (welfare dependence). If you believe that the government is ultimately responsible, you might make different mistakes, like 1. assume that a certain political party could fix everything "if only" they were in power (ideologue) or 2. try to get rid of all government because everything they do is ''bad" (anarchy) or 3. simply believe there is no solution since the government will never be effective (apathy). So what is the "correct perspective"? Obviously that's up for debate, but I think a few aspects are key: respect for local culture, dedication, openness to compromise, and a constant search for balance between bronca and paciencia--anger and patience--when considering how things should.. must.. be different.
Maintaining that perspective as much as possible, and after some tough thinking--and arguing--we came up with the following:
Project name: Cocina Comunidad
Location: Community La Misión, Rivadavia Banda Sur, Salta, Argentina
Beneficiaries: 60 Wichí families
Duration: 9 meses
Goal: Develop a sustainable system to guarantee food security and an improved quality of life for all community members
Objectives:
a. Build and equip a communal, ecological kitchen
b. Facilitate the production of vegetables and poultry for consumption by establishing a community garden and chicken coop
c. To introduce basic principles of health and hygiene to the community, especially in younger generations
d. Highlight the ongoing environmental damage that is occurring in the region and teach the community about their part in reversing it by living in harmony with the fragile ecosystem
e. Promote community integration and gender equality by encouraging the establishment of an inclusive Committee on Health and Culture within the community.
As is evident from the title and objectives of the project, our first priority is community. That priority is reflected in a major and unique part of this project that is not described above: our team will be living in the community itself. Whenever we tell people that, they look at us as if we were a little crazy. And maybe it is, but we strongly reject the idea of helping by doing for rather than doing with. No matter how great the might be, those who would come in and make big changes and then simply leave could not afterwards expect for their idea to have continuity or be sustainable. Change comes not from outsiders providing solutions according to their own criteria but from the integrated efforts of a community dedicated to their own progress. Achieving that requires forming a lasting and genuine relationship with the community.
The project focuses on the problem of malnutrition because we believe it is a stumbling block to development and is elemental in the continuation of the circle of poverty we are trying to break. Without proper nutrition, children cannot perform as well in school. If children are not well educated, as adults they will likely be less productive. If adults are less productive, they cannot provide food for their children. This is not even considering negative health outcomes, which also stunt development and can generate exorbitant costs for the whole family. Furthermore, having a local source of food will increase their economic power by freeing up other money that would be normally spent on expensive fruits and vegetables.
Time will tell if we are successful or not, but I think hope and fate our on our side. People's living conditions all around the world are slowly improving, and the Wichí should not be left out of that process. I am moving to the region this week, and hope to be able to continue updating about the progress we are making and my struggles as director of the project. I want to thank REVO @ Pacific Union College for supporting this project--for believing this kind of change is possible--and for all of those who have helped both me personally and ADRA in general. ¡Hasta luego!
Subscribe to:
Posts
