Sunday, May 16, 2010

La vida salteña

I think this will probably be the entry that is most difficult for me to write. It's not that I have anything controversial to say (yet), but that it's very difficult to put into words the atmosphere of the city that surrounds me, and the little part that I play in it. Salta has so much beauty--both natural and cultural--that any attempt to describe it seems to leave something out. As for my part in it, at the moment it seems rather mundane in comparison, but it's impossible to understand what I'm doing here without that wonderfully/painfully inevitable word: context.

I must admit that my knowledge of Argentinian history is rather sparse. It's mostly pieced together from the little I remember about Latin America from History and Spanish classes, reading a rather biased but informative account of the military government that took over in the 70s ("The Shock Doctrine"), and picking up little snippits from signs at tourist attractions. But, in a nutshell (from my semi-ignorant perspective.. find the real history
here), General San Martín, hyped up on the recent American and French Revolutions, helps to liberate South America from hundreds of years of Spanish colonial rule of a land rich in resources and native culture (the Spanish weren't so interested in the latter). Argentina declares independence May 25, 1810 (bicentennial just passed), and form a constitution on July 9, 1816. Argentina enters the modern market, and Europeans flood in by the thousands (indigenous peoples now make up less than 1% of the population). The democratic government takes hold, but occasionally suffers military overthrows, the latest ending in 1983. Argentina remains a powerful economy, but is held back (in my view) by a deadly combination of privatization and corruption, epitomized by former President Menem. (I apologize if this short history contains some heinous errors. I feel it is important to show what I "know", even if incorrect).

Salta seems to have been pivotal throughout this history. In my mind it is an anchor point both historically and geographically in South America, with threads fingering out to the north that connect it with indigenous and Incan roots, and southernly fibers that, while perhaps weaker, link it to colonial and modern influences. This makes Salta feel quite a bit different than the rest Argentina, because of its lasting resemblance to the Andean cultures of nearby Bolivia and Perú. Being such an anchor implies a certain amount of conflict (think of other anchors like Washington, D.C., London, Rome, etc.). They are places of both violence and victory, suffering and pride, history and future. Salta is no exception, and in this respect its cultural foundations reflect perfectly its environmental make-up, an incomprehensible clash of desert and jungle that converge in the Lerma Valley that holds the provincial capital (see this map). Although there is a constant tension between competing forces--whether they be climatic or cultural--the resulting beauty that somehow endures makes the tenuous balance much more interesting and rich than if it weren't there. As for those who live here, I don't think I would be overextending my "geo-cultural" analogy to suggest that the soaring mountains that rise over the valley not only represent but embody the achievements, aspirations, and struggles that together define what it means to be "salteño" (someone from Salta). It's all part of what makes Salta live up to its' nickname, "la linda" (the beautiful).

(aside: by way of example, my host-father once joked during one of his impromptu history lessons--typically given on motorcycle rides--that "the fighting [for independence from Spain] started in 1810, but we're still not sure who won!". In the context of my analogy, I think it's significant that he made that statement as we passed a war memorial that lies on the edge of Salta, and is therefore the first thing you would see coming into town from a scenic route to the north that is particularly beautiful and diverse)

I feel very lucky to be in such an interesting place, but to be honest my tension is by proportion much less significant. It's not torrential downpour vs. insufferable drought, noble gauchos vs. Spanish oppressors (see here), or military dictators vs. rebel students (see here). My conflict is much more internal: between feeling useful but uncomfortable on the one hand, and feeling utterly insignificant but comfortable on the other (and from the tone of this entry so far, you could probably guess which is currently winning).

It may sound backwards, but I think most people before going out into the field expect--even want--the former. Maybe it's just me, but it seems that part of feeling like you've accomplished a lot requires feeling like you sacrificed a lot, too. In fact, it's the subtext to the saying, "Rome wasn't built in a day": something so substantial should demand a huge input of time and work. (entirely unrelated, but thinking of Roman proverbs reminds me of that hilarious Anchorman moment: "please.. continue"). Obviously sacrifice is not the only element of feeling useful--we can all remember moments where we "gave our all" and still didn't meet our goals--but I think it would be difficult for me to think that I had done something really great without having used a lot of energy and maybe even felt some pain. In other words, felt uncomfortable.

That has been my problem: I feel too comfortable. I thought that by leaving my home and going off into a foreign land to help the less fortunate would be really hard. The fact is, I've simply transported my already comfortable life to a different place. Yes, there are slight differences--I now eat dinner really late at night (sometimes at 11PM), ride the bus instead of drive my Dad's van, and use the internet a lot less (only during siesta or late at night)--but for the most part I live each day thinking, "This shouldn't be so easy!". I can wake up late, my two hosts--Graciela and Beatriz--spoil me worse than my mom and Cynthia combined (they don't let me do the dishes or laundry!), and confusions and stand-stills in conversation are happening much less often, so I'm having a great time getting to know their families and friends. I even have something I don't have at home: a steady tennis partner! Getting lost on the bus for an hour and a half and waiting in the cold for a few hours after watching Michael Jackson's "This Is It" at the local Hoyt's seem like mild inconveniences in comparison with all the good things I've been given here.

And, while the promise of hard work lies on the horizon, for now it's just not as demanding as I expected. My "first day" seemed a lot like the others, just that I woke up earlier, met a veteran volunteer of ADRA Salta (Pilu), and learned the bus route to one of the ADRA depositories. In a whole week of work, all I seemed to be able to accomplish was to organize some clothes to send on a trip I couldn't go on. I tried to make that feel important, but at the end of the day, taping together pairs of disorganized shoe donations hardly felt like the intense, difficult regimen that I was looking for in my humanitarian (ad)venture. What is missing? Have I really just been self-righteous in my attempt to be self-sacrificing? Is it possible to feel both comfortable and useful?

What I've come to realize is that the humanitarian adventure is an illusion. It is foolish--and very American--to think that with some determination and hard work you can start to turn things around in an instant. "Dream big", "reach for the stars", "be all you can be", "impossible is nothing", "just do it"... these are the mottoes that drive us. Although I think it's hard to argue that the optimistic dedication these phrases inspire could be a bad thing, I do think it is terribly misguided. A failure to work within our limitations--whether they be personal, institutional, or systemic--leads to one of two undesirable outcomes: 1. dissatisfaction with work that does not live up to our grand expectations, or 2. exaggeration of work that wasn't actually as great as we make it seem. This is a terrible dilemma, because there is no such thing as perfect work. As long is that is true, the overly-optimistic humanitarian will always see "room for improvement" as failure, or, to compensate, remain in denial that improvements in the work were really necessary.

Unfortunately, this is one of those situations where I know the solution to my problem but it still seems unsolvable. It's hard to disillusion-ize myself. That is, it's easier to recognize my limitations (personal, institutional, systemic) than it is to accept and work within them. I recognize that I am impatient, but it is hard to be patient. I want to feel like I'm making significant changes right now, even though I know that change for the good can take a lot longer than I would like. It's easy to recognize the institutional limitations of time, money, and disorganization that face ADRA in Argentina, but much more difficult to acknowledge them instead of simply getting angry at them. It's perhaps easiest to recognize the limitations of the system we live in--the lack of real help we provide to those in need, and all of the social, political, and cultural pressures that get in the way of doing so--yet these are the things that seem nearly impossible to change.

So, now you can see (and me too, in writing all of this out) that while small, my internal conflicts have the power to really affect my work, and, perhaps more importantly, my perspective on my work. Breaking down my illusions while maintaining a healthy level of optimism could prove to be a difficult task, especially when the possibility of feeling both useless and uncomfortable looms darkly in the corner. Learning how to feel productive by finding the right balance between sacrifice and suffering--i.e. suffer physically by working too much, or mentally by working too little--could be even harder. No pain, no gain?

(p.s. sorry for all the text, you can find some of my pictures of Salta here)

Friday, May 14, 2010

¡A Salta!

So I'm going to pick up where I left off, more or less (events correspond to November of 2009):

I've made a huge mistake. If I've learned anything so far it's that risking the appearance of having the intelligence of a four-year-old by asking more questions is better than assuming you know what's going on. In the end, you'll feel like a four-year-old when what you understood was terribly wrong. I learned the hard way that just because you buy a bus ticket at the terminal, does not necessarily mean that that bus leaves from the same terminal, or even the same town. I learned the hard way that if you miss your bus, there is no way to get your money back. And, I learned the hard way that it's stupid to call a up a company expecting them to help you when the error was so clearly personal (5 minutes and 9 pesos later).

So I played it off to just about everyone that I had actually bought my ticket for the next day, "surprising" my friends by having an extra night and day to hang out. The next day, I did the right (obvious?) thing by taking the earlier, smaller bus to the bigger town to take the bigger bus. Fortunately, as opposed to some of my experiences on buses in 2008, the ride was very comfortable. Not excessively hot, no pirated movies playing full-blast, and a relatively clean bathroom. I even slept for a significant portion of it, which I can't even do on planes! And the view coming into Salta was stunning. Although I had already visited Salta before, this entrance (from the South, instead of the East) gave an overlook of nearly the entire city, the towers of the cathedrals rising high above Salta's mostly low-rise skyline. Descending down that mountain pass, it dawned on me that this was home.

That realization became even more real when I arrived a few minutes later at the terminal. I think that one of the most important qualifications of a home is that you have people that come to pick you up when you arrive. My boss and soon to be adoptive mother, Beatriz, was there with her temporarily shy 8-year-old daughter, Elena, as well as the wisecracking ADRA driver, "Juancito". (A quick aside: in Spanish you can basically throw "ito/a" onto any word as a diminutive, and on names it becomes an endearing nickname. In Salta this is very common, so instead of "pan" for bread it's "pancito", and instead of "agua" for water it's "aguita". This becomes another case of my name being the least international of all names, because calling me Zachito without a "z" sound in Spanish makes it sound like "saquito", the dimunitive for a coat.) We packed the stuff into the car and headed off towards "home", an apartment complex (called "Parque La Vega") that lies about 7km south of downtown. On the drive I only recognized a few things from my last trip: San Martín Plaza, where you can rent swan-shaped paddle-boats by day, or find services considerably less innocent by night; and the San Bernardo mountain, which for 14 pesos a piece has a gondola that will take you to the top to see the whole city from a bird's-eye view (still haven't done it!). Everything else, however, seemed new. The soccer stadium, the high-end car dealerships, and a whole string of warehouses and distribution centers.

Although it must have taken less than 15 minutes, the trip seemed like an eternity. I had entirely forgotten about the other crucial qualification of home: living space. Before leaving to Argentina I had in mind that I would try to live in an apartment on my own, rather than risk the possible--and probable--conflicts that might arise out of staying with a conservative Adventist family. Here I was, sitting in the car, heading off to who knows where, without the slightest plan or idea of how to sensitively ask about my housing options. Again my fears seemed to be in excess of the reality, as the arrangement had already been made for me long in advance. I live just around the corner from Beatriz in the home of a widow, Graciela, who is equally liberal and perhaps more fiery than Beatriz herself... at least when it comes to leaving things on the floor or not making my bed! On top of that, she runs a kiosk out of her living room, so for better or worse I have constant access to a whole slew of goodies, not least of which are the delicious "facturas" (pastries) I get to eat every morning for breakfast with mate cocido (mate in teabags instead of free leaves).

Like English, Spanish has a clear distinction between house and home ("casa" and "hogar").
In both languages they can be used interchangeably, but if we are being specific a house is really just a place, while a home adds an element of humanity. A house can only be a home if there is a person that feels that way towards that location. In addition to the two qualities of home I have already mentioned--people and place--I think the real difference between house and home consists in our pattern of life, the daily rhythm of what we do in and around the house we live in. For that reason, it could possibly weeks or months before I really feel like this new place is actually my home. Only at some point in the future will I be able to assess whether I really feel comfortable in this "hogar", or whether that concept will be forever tied to my two homes in the US (Angwin and Takoma Park), and being in Salta will remain only as a "casa" until the moment I leave.

¿Adónde fuiste?

So, it's been awhile since my last post. 5 months and 12 days, to be a little more precise (thanks www.timeanddate.com). Whoever continues to read this is probably more interested in an update rather than a post with an explanation for why I haven't been writing, but for my own reasons and for those who may be interested, I feel it's necessary. So here they are, listed in order of importance:

1. Laziness. The simple fact of the matter is that it's not easy to write every two weeks, which was my original plan. It takes a lot of dedication and drive, and I was seriously lacking in those two departments.

2. Fear. Something that I learned from blogging is that you should always know who your audience is. In college it's easy to write whatever you feel like without any repercussions (apart from grades, obviously), because your only audience is a professor. On the world wide web, however, just about anyone can access your thoughts if you put them out there. Word got back to me that the assistant to the director of ADRA Argentina had been reading, and even though we are good friends, the implications of that made me feel a little restricted. In addition, some of my Argentinian friends were not entirely happy with some of my characterizations of their culture. I realize now I should have been more careful criticizing another culture as easily as I criticize my own.

3. Time. I am busy. Sometimes it may not seem that way when you see me on Facebook, but I really do have a lot of responsibilities here. When I do have free time, it's not exactly the most fun or relaxing thing to sum up the energy to write, rather than decompress.

So there you have it, folks. A short sum-up of my absence from the blogging world. I can't promise that I'll be getting back on the horse, but I'm going to try. Or, to use one of my favorite Bart Simpson quotes, "I can't promise you I'll try, but I'll try to try."

Thursday, December 3, 2009

La villa pt. 3: Viviendo en Adventlandia

Although the express purpose of my visit to the UAP was to attend the ADRA planning meetings, I had actually already been planning on passing through on my way to Salta so I could catch up with some people from my college (Pacific Union College). My friend Cheyenne went here last year and, as is common practice, picked up a significant other. Since I wasn't too hyped on the idea of staying with a pastor, her boyfriend Isa (for Isaiah) kindly put me up at his apartment for the week. Of course, most pastors are nice enough, but those from latinoamerica kind of have a reputation that I wasn't ready to test just yet. Ironically, I later found out that he was away that week, and after having met his agreeable family I felt pretty stupid for opting out.

Still, staying with Isa was a great experience. Not only did he have a fan in his room to battle the stupendous heat of that week (made worse by the dress clothes I was wearing for half the day), he knows everyone in town. The somewhat long walk to the university from his place was made shorter by all the people we greeted along the way, and almost every night we hung out with his friends at the local futsal gym (5 on 5 indoor soccer) to watch the yearly tournament of teams from the whole town. It was especially fun to watch his team compete, as well as play ping-pong when I got a little bored with the endless futsal (the level of play for ping pong was inexplicably high—I lost every time, to multiple players). Besides that, his landlords were also extremely nice, always offering me dinner at night and terere (mate with chilled juice/soda instea
d of hot water) in the afternoons. In contrast to the typical Argentinian stereotype of self-inflating machismo, I have found no lack of kindness and their hospitality is incredibly generous. Even with the slimmest of connections, you become family in an instant. I think my only complaint I could possibly have is with their diet, which apart from an excess of meat-eating also involves a love of mayonnaise I didn't think was possible. Gross.

Another slight difficulty was that I was essentially without access to the internet except during meeting breaks. In addition to creating incredible withdrawals, this made meeting up with the people I knew somewhat of a task for the first couple days. Eventually I spotted Meagan (from my Spanish class last year) and Mike (who I mentioned earlier) in the cafeteria, and as we caught up a couple other familiar faces from PUC dropped by as well. That's when I realized how crucial a shared culture and language are to interacting with other people. People I had barely seen before instantly became friends I was hugging, and acquaintances now became hang out partners for hours on end. Yes, part of it is a chance to escape from speaking in Spanish—the 4th grade vocabulary, the same topics over and over, the feelings of stupidity—but it's also a relief from the constant struggle to understand the character and traits of the people I'm interacting with. Language is central to our ability make snap judgments about people: whether they are kind or mean, intelligent or foolish, easygoing or uptight, etc. (even sane or insane, as I found out during my time at Napa State Hospital). Without that ability, I am basically left at the mercy of what people I already know tell me about others. Usually this works, but it's obviously very dangerous to base your opinion of someone solely from the perspective of someone else.


At any rate, I had a good time in the idyllic village of Adventism. Seeing old friends is always a pleasure, and making new ones is an adventure. I can't wait to go back to enjoy cheap ice cream, bicycle shenanigans, and most of all, the feeling of being a place full of great people that you know or are soon to meet. I will definitely miss it.

Sunday, November 15, 2009

La villa pt. 2: Los reuniones

Starting this week I added another link in the chain of my participation in the Seventh-Day Adventist “system”. That chain began almost literally at birth, followed by grade school, academy, and college, along with my church membership confirmed by baptism at age 12. And now, work (with the Adventist Development and Relief Agency, if you didn't know). It should be noted that this is not uncommon. The potential to forever remain in the SDA subcultural bubble is very real, and often desirable, for many Adventists. Whether you're an Angwinite, Loma Linder, or a Caroll Avenue kid (or countless other SDA niches), you know that there is always a place for you if you want to stick around.

Depending on your school, church, and friends, however, your “SDA life” could look very different from someone else's. That is because, like any religious community, SDAs are far from monolithic. I, for example, grew up in a rather liberal version of SDAism that puts it's emphasis on mainstream Christian theology and values, while shying away from prophecy, orthodox Sabbath-keeping, and the writings of Ellen G. White (though I did write a paper that showed how pervasive she is in our literature, even when unmentioned). That version seems to be virtually nonexistent in South America, and it has therefore been a little difficult to cope with my new situation, even though we are supposedly the same (I had to laugh to myself when I agreed with someone that I was experiencing some “culture shock”; not—like they thought—from being in Argentina, but from being amongst conservative SDAs).

I say only a little difficult because most of the things that really separate me from these SDAs are ideas, which are rarely communicated—in either direction—due to my partial language barrier. Yes, praying before every meal and singing songs before a planning meeting is a little foreign to me, but certainly not alien. As for the ideas, the solution is simple: keep my mouth shut. Even if I hear an idea I think I disagree with, I remain content to keep silent for fear of attacking a point they didn't actually make and/or making myself look like an idiot, or worse, an apostate. Perhaps I am not standing up for myself, but as both an outsider and a new employee, it seems easy enough to justify it as social and cultural sensitivity.

The first two days of meetings were unbearably boring (not only that, they started at 8 AM, death for a night owl like myself). Hours and hours were spent describing the the history of ADRA, it's financial and administrative structure, and overviews of the national emergency plan we would eventually be constructing. The only benefit was the snack breaks, which made up for the breakfast I didn't have (decaf tea with cookies and tasty little cheesy breadballs). The only time my ears pricked up were when the words “evangelism” and “proselytism” came up in a long discussion of ADRA's purpose. This is because I am definitively against evangelism, especially in it's typical SDA form: fear tactics and emotional appeals based on the doom-and-gloom Bible prophecies of Daniel and Revelation. To me an emphasis on prophecy has the potential to create passive people who, while they recognize that the world is getting progressively worse, choose to analyze the decline as a “sign of the times” rather than take an active role in preventing it. Furthermore, in my view, evangelism merely reflects the hubris of the group that is proselytizing, as it suggests that their perspective is true to the exclusion of all others. It's not so much that I disagree with the SDA message, but that it I think it only has partial truth—just like the other religions it is trying to convert people from (more on this later).

This is why I love ADRA, because while it is funded by the Church, it is not associated with any religious motive apart from the imperative of the social gospel (i.e. Jesus' call to help the poor, the orphaned, the widowed, the “least of these”). Unlike other sectors of the Church, it refuses to overspiritualize Christianity into a matter solely of belief to the exclusion of living a life of discipleship, doing good for the sake of goodness. Thinking that this view was common, I felt great discomfort when one person kept interrupting to insist that we are doing
nothing if we are only giving bread and water and not the “bread of life” (i.e. the spiritual gospel). I felt something close to horror when someone suggested that we put SDA literature in relief packages, and even more so that the only response to that idea was not that it was contrary to ADRA's mission, but that doing so could create legal problems with governments that are unfriendly to proselytism.

As it turns out, keeping my mouth shut was a very prudent decision. First, because this kind of talk eventually disappeared as real work on the emergency plan began. Second, because I later found out that the people making those arguments were Church administrators, not ADRA representatives. Third, and most importantly, my local supervisor is in accord with my thoughts on the social gospel, and conducts all of her work on that principle. Although we disagree on some things, it has been a great comfort that I seem to have found the most open minded SDA in Argentina, so that I do not have to pretend to be something I am not for the sake of my work. Her determination and attitude really shines in comparison to the other regional directors I met, who were thoroughly lackluster.

For the most part I tried to stay off to the side during the planning sessions, but eventually I got dragged into being at least somewhat productive. After about half a day of trying to figure out what they wanted me to do, I finally realized that I was to draft the response “menu” for attending to psychological health in the case of a natural disaster. Although I was certainly not qualified to do so, with a little research—and a lot of help from a few bilingual aides—I was able to create something acceptable. So in reality the meetings weren't all bad. In fact, the EVP of ADRA told my boss that he took some of my ideas about the psychological health of volunteers—i.e. not just the affected—and is planning on working them into ADRA International's response plan.

I want to finish with a return to the evangelism issue, because I have been thinking about it a lot now that I am in a context where it is common. In the United States, where individual domain is sacred, it is very easy to hold the opinion that I related earlier. In Argentina, however, I can't seem to refute the many positive benefits people face when they join the SDA church. For me, I care most about the practical impact of evangelism. I definitely do not like it when conversion destroys a family—which is common in very Catholic families—but for many people it gives them a new energy in life that seems to save them from many pitfalls in life: addiction, disease, poverty. In pondering that point, I think I have come to understand what my esteemed professor, Dr. Greg Schneider, meant when he said—echoing William James—that the validity of a religion comes from “fruits not roots”. That is, from what they accomplish, not from what they believe. What do you think?

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

La villa pt. 1: Mirando atrás

While I am sure that during the six months I am here in Argentina I will experience a great deal of life-altering moments, I think there are three big transitions that stand out. The first transition was obviously moving from San Francisco to Argentina, and the third will be when I take a 20 hour bus ride to the impoverished northern provinces of Salta and Jujuy (hoo-hooey!). I have a feeling that the second was the most difficult: leaving liberal leftist Buenos Aires and entering the conservative, nearly fundamentalist world of latino Adventism.

There is one word that can encapsulate my feelings as I made that trip to “la villa” (puiggari/libertador san martin/la
UAP): regret. The first regret I had was that I found out too late that the famed superclásico—a soccer match which is basically on my bucket list to see en vivo—would not be taking place some time after I arrived in Salta, but the same Sunday I was leaving to the villa. Not only that, we ended up traveling during the game, so I was reduced to listening to it on the radio, which is basically useless for someone who wasn't born into the language. Unlike football or baseball, soccer has no breaks to allow for a slower summary of what is going on, so the live commentary is outrageously fast—and constant. What's more, the game took place at River stadium, and it was a tie: perfect conditions for seeing a great game with minimal risk of riots. ¡Qué lástima!

The second regret was that my Spanish (or “castellano”, to Argentinians) was not holding up too well. Whenever Paula, the ADRA assistant, called to make plans to pick me up, I was always eternally confused. The phrases “dos y media” and “doce y media” sound nearly identical over the phone, yet it represents a two hour difference in time. Besides my difficulties with the phone, I couldn't say everything I wanted to in person either. Without an adequate vocabulary it was difficult to express the deep gratitude I had for the Gambetta's hospitality and friendship. Although I did get them some presents, just saying “muchisimas gracias” (many many thanks) didn't quite seem to do it.

Because of those failures of Spanish proficiency, when I arrived at the UAP I had a very strong regret that I had not come there earlier in my college career—or maybe even this year, like my friend Mike Ha is doing. I had had quite a few more Spanish “fails” on our 4 hour journey over vast plains and swamplands (e.g. crecimiento=rising river levels, not a tunnel), and had plenty of time to think about how much easier it might have been to just be in school again, not for intense graduate studies but a relaxed study of a language I love. It's really part of a culminating feeling I've had since I graduated in June, that for the first time in my life I am no longer looking forward to the future, but treasuring and missing the past.

I have always wanted to be older, never younger (I suppose it's the combination of having an older brother and having parents that treat you like an adult). In elementary school I knew I wanted to go to
Walla Walla to become an engineer so I could design roller coasters (which I was ironically afraid to ride). In middle school I played ping pong with CUC students and yearned to be among them as equals. In high school I was on track to be an ascetic pastor who would change the world for the good. And in college, as confused as I became with my desired career plans, I still had visions of reaching the Ivy League in the years beyond. So now, as I enter the working world, it is difficult to cope with the fact that I have already come to and passed the Golden Age that I had looked forward to as a youth. All that shimmers is sure to fade away, but will I fade too? Is it humility or disappointment that has led me to think that my time has passed? Is it possible that being a “grown-up” just means realizing how little influence you'll really have?

Unfortunately I think that those questions will persist for a long time, and being constantly asked, “What exactly are you doing here?” by people around the UAP definitely doesn't help. I just want to shout “I don't know! Why didn't someone tell me to just come here?”. Still, I have been able to take a little bit more pride in saying, “No, I don't go to school here, I am an ADRA volunteer”. Maybe it's just my justification, but it seems that there has to be something honorable about not taking the comfortable route. Going back to college would have been easy, fun, and comfortable, but ultimately self-serving. Thanks to the advice of some friends and my own conscience, I have forced myself into the position of being a servant, something I have always wanted to be but never had the courage to really try. Vamos a ver ("we'll see how it goes").

(P.S. sorry for another old photo, but it's from Puiggari and seems to capture the spirit of this entry, more or less)

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Un día en el centro

So... I gave in. With so much prodding from both friends (Tamara) and Richi--one of the family who continually makes jokes about me that I only partly understand--I finally decided to make a significant trip beyond the walls of the house. Another reason I hadn't ventured out is because the metro is so far away, and therefore requires using the very complicated bus system (there are over 300 lines). However, when I asked they said I could take a train that had a stop only 4 blocks away that would get me to the downtown metro. Juli had been a little scared to use this form of public transportation, but I guess they felt I was up to it. For the most part it went fine, except on the way back when I got lost amongst the three separate train stations at my destination, not remembering at which I had arrived (and no help from the ticket-taker, who just said "That doesn't work here" and tore up my pass).

I got off the metro near the Plaza de Mayo, walking by the famous Cafe Tortoni and through the street performer and vendor-laden business district of Avenida Florida. As per usual, there was a tango fusion type group with a great accordionist, and a smaller, traditional Andean band with panflutes. Also added to the mix was a group of dreadlocked reggae-ers (singing "listen to mother earth" and "in my home I have a dog, not a gun"), a subculture which seems to be taking a greater hold now more than it was a year ago. I also passed by the Obelisk (pictured above), which is probably the most famous structure in the city (it's in the middle of a 15 lane road!).

After awhile I felt like going over to the art museums of Recoleta, but remembered from my Lonely Planet guide that Thursday afternoons are when the Madres de la Plaza de Mayo march in front of the Casa Rosada (our equivalent of the White House, but pink). This was an event I had wanted to see since I read about them in Naomi Klein's The Shock Doctrine. There is a
fascinating history behind these women, who continue to plead for a full investigation into the "disappearance" of approximately 30,000 individuals during Argentina's military dictatorship from 1976-1983 ("The Dirty War"), some of which were their own children. The Madres are now a significant grassroots organization, supporting a variety of left-leaning political positions. It really was amazing to watch them and the veterans from the Maldives War (the Falkland War), despite the presence of street vendors trying to capitalize on the spectacle.

After catching part of an evensong by some local catholic school kids at the National Cathedral, I hopped on the metro towards Palermo, an upscale region of Buenos Aires that is peppered with parks, monuments, and museums. I spent a lot of time walking, seeing small groups talking and drinking their afternoon mate, playing soccer, and even a few skateboarding. Eventually I landed at the Museo de Arte Latinoamericano de Buenos Aires (MALBA), a modern/contemporary art museum that on the outside looks a lot like the East Wing of the National Gallery in D.C., and inside feels like the archetypal modern art museum. They had a Warhol exhibition opening the next day called "Mr. America", of which I was unfortunately only able to see a very small part.

After I left, I was about halfway to Recoleta, a bordering barrio that houses a super-upscale mall, the famous "aristocrat-only" Recoleta Cemetary, and my favorite place in Buenos Aires, the Fine Arts Museum. If there was one thing I was going to go back to see, it was going to be that. The museum was just as great as I remembered, and the upstairs--which I missed before--had a great collection of Argentinian modern works. Still, their European modern selections trumped all, and I was really moved by this small-but-interesting Pollock (clearly this photo cannot do it justice!).

By far the most interesting part of my journey, however, was the sculpture garden behind the museum which I had somehow missed last year. It holds a massive--it must be at least 50 ft. tall--flower sculpture that moves according to how much light is hitting it, mimicking its biological counterpart. It was really fascinating to see it at different points in its movement during sunset, which allowed me to mostly overlook the fact that it was engineered by Lockheed Martin.

It was getting late and I was tired, so I stopped by a cafe on the way back to the train station to have a mocha and "medialunas" (literally half-moon, i.e. croissants). Clearly they knew I was going to drop by, because they were blasting a mix of the remastered Beatles albums. How could I resist? I almost considered buying the albums earlier in the day, but looking at the prices I realized why pirating is the norm here. Each album was about 75 pesos, and the new Mika album was nearly 90! With the exchange that only made them about $5 more than what I assume is the average for a CD in the US, but with salaries here being about the same (in number, not in value), I couldn't imagine spending that much on a single CD.

And that is the reality of Argentina: the image of prosperity despite significant poverty. Billions of dollars have obviously been poured into beautiful shopping centers and the restoration of it's European center, but for the most part it is an illusion. Certainly there is a sector of Argentinian society that somewhat corresponds to the super-rich of the states, but the majority seem to be in a class that roughly mirrors our lower-middle-class. I say seem because you can see it when you walk down the street: businessmen wearing cheap suits and worn-down loafers, women with old purses and unshined heels, and teenagers with imitation jerseys and Adidas futsal shoes aged to perfection. And poverty is never far away. On the trains the impoverished make long speeches asking for money in return for a variety of cheap goods/food (harmonicas and socks, mostly), outside the station they casually pick through the trash, and at every stoplight they juggle balls or attempt to wash your windshield. This is only, of course, what you see; there are places where even locals don't go--villas ("slums") that creep relatively close to the center of BA--much less an American tourist.

Still, the situation has improved immensely since the 2001 crash. Obviously more needs to be done, but I won't bore you with my perspective on how that should be done, and you probably already have a general idea of what it would be :). At any rate, I had a great day, but it was also extremely long (like this entry?) so my feet hurt a lot, and I'm still trying to apologize for giving the family a bit of a scare for arriving later than they expected. Chau chau for now.